Skip to content
(03) 9380 8099
A practitioner raising a patient's leg to test hip and knee movement during an assessment

Chiropractic

Shoulder, hip and knee pain: what the assessment separates

Joint pain in a shoulder, hip or knee is rarely the joint alone. How referred pain is ruled out, and when it points somewhere else.

Last reviewed

People book for a sore shoulder, a sore hip or a sore knee expecting the appointment to be about that joint. Often it is. Reasonably often it is not, and the first useful thing an assessment does is establish which situation you are in.

The pain is not always where the problem is

Joints and nerves refer pain in patterns that do not match how most people picture their anatomy.

Hip osteoarthritis classically presents as groin or outer thigh pain, and in a proportion of people it presents as knee pain with no hip symptoms at all. Lower back problems refer into the buttock and down the thigh, which is frequently mistaken for a hip problem. Neck problems refer into the shoulder blade and upper arm, which is frequently mistaken for a shoulder problem.

This is why a shoulder examination includes the neck, and why a knee that examines entirely normally prompts a look at the hip and lower back rather than a scan of the knee. Treating the painful area when the source is elsewhere is the most common reason joint treatment does not work.

Joint problem or tendon problem

Once the source is localised, the next split matters more than the diagnosis label, because it changes what treatment should mostly consist of.

Joint-driven pain — stiffness after rest, pain through a range of movement, discomfort that eases as you warm up — tends to respond well to manual therapy alongside movement. Hands-on treatment is a reasonable lead here.

Tendon-driven pain — rotator cuff at the shoulder, gluteal tendons at the outside of the hip, patellar or quadriceps tendon at the knee — behaves differently. It is load-related, it hurts on specific loaded tests rather than through the whole range, and it responds primarily to progressively loaded exercise. Manual therapy and shockwave therapy can help with symptoms, but the loading programme is what changes the tendon. A tendon problem managed with hands-on treatment alone will feel better and stay fragile.

Being told which of these you have, and therefore what will actually do the work, is a reasonable thing to expect from a first appointment.

Why scans mislead here more than almost anywhere

Rotator cuff tears are present on imaging in a large proportion of people over 60 who have no shoulder pain whatsoever. Meniscal tears are common findings in painless knees. Joint space narrowing appears in people who are walking around without complaint.

So a scan will find something, and being told you have a tear tends to reduce how much people use the limb — which for most shoulder and knee problems is the opposite of what helps.

Imaging is worth doing when the result would change what happens next: significant trauma, a joint that locks or gives way, suspected serious pathology, a surgical opinion under consideration, or symptoms that are not following the course they should be. Those are real thresholds and they get met. “I would like to see what is torn” is not one of them.

Signs that need medical assessment before treatment

  • A joint that is hot, swollen and painful without a clear injury — especially with fever. That needs same-day medical assessment
  • Inability to bear weight after an injury, or an obviously deformed joint
  • A knee that locks, or a joint that gives way repeatedly
  • Several joints becoming painful and swollen at the same time, with morning stiffness lasting over an hour — a pattern that can indicate inflammatory arthritis
  • Unexplained weight loss, night pain that will not settle, or a history of cancer alongside new joint pain

The practitioners here are trained to spot these, and screen for them at every first appointment. If you describe any of them to us, we will tell you the same thing and help you get seen rather than book you in — and for anything that turns out not to be on this list, that is exactly the sort of thing the practitioners here see every day.

What treatment involves

For most shoulder, hip and knee pain, some combination of the following.

Hands-on treatment of what testing implicated — the joint itself, the surrounding muscles, and the region referring into it where that applies.

Loading, progressed deliberately. This is the part that changes capacity rather than just symptoms, and it is where most of the improvement comes from in tendon-related problems. It has to be uncomfortable enough to drive adaptation and controlled enough not to flare, which is why it is prescribed and reviewed rather than handed over as a sheet.

Adjusting what provoked it. Training volume that climbed too fast, a job that changed, a return to sport after a lay-off, or a new desk. Something usually changed shortly before the pain started, and finding it is often more useful than any individual technique.

Making sure you see the right practitioner

Chiropractic scope covers the joints and muscles of the whole body, so shoulders, hips and knees are legitimately within it. Being able to treat something is not the same as being the best-placed person to lead it, and there are clear cases where the answer sits elsewhere:

  • Tendon problems where the main intervention is a months-long loading programme are usually better led by physiotherapy
  • Foot and ankle mechanics driving knee pain, and anything needing orthotics or nail care, belong with podiatry
  • Suspected inflammatory arthritis, infection or fracture is a medical diagnosis, not an allied health one
  • A joint that has reached the point of a surgical conversation needs a specialist opinion, and delaying that with a further course of conservative care serves nobody

All three professions work in this building, so being redirected is a conversation rather than a new referral and another waiting list.

Questions

Common questions

Can a chiropractor treat shoulder, hip and knee pain?

Yes — chiropractic scope covers the joints and muscles of the whole body, not only the spine. The practical question is whether hands-on treatment is the right lead for your particular problem. Tendon problems, for example, respond mainly to progressively loaded exercise, so those are often better led by physiotherapy with hands-on work as a support rather than the main event.

Why does my knee hurt when the problem is in my hip?

Joints refer pain, and they refer it in patterns that do not respect anatomy as most people picture it. Hip osteoarthritis classically presents as groin or thigh pain and sometimes as knee pain alone, and lower back problems can refer into the buttock and thigh. That is why a knee that examines completely normally prompts examination of the hip and lower back rather than a scan of the knee.

Do I need a scan for shoulder or knee pain?

Usually not at first. Rotator cuff tears, meniscal tears and joint degeneration all appear commonly on scans of people with no symptoms, so a finding is not automatically the cause. Imaging earns its place when the result would change the plan — a suspected significant tear, a locked or giving-way knee, trauma, or symptoms not following the expected course.

How long does a tendon problem take to improve?

Longer than most people are told. Tendons adapt slowly, and a meaningful change in a rotator cuff, gluteal or patellar tendon problem is usually measured in three to six months of consistent loading rather than weeks. Pain often improves well before capacity does, which is the point at which people stop the exercises and the problem returns.

When does joint pain need medical assessment before treatment?

A joint that is hot, swollen and painful without an obvious injury, particularly with fever, needs same-day medical assessment. So does a joint that will not bear weight after an injury, an obvious deformity, a joint that locks or gives way repeatedly, or multiple joints becoming painful and swollen together — that last pattern can indicate inflammatory arthritis, which is diagnosed on blood tests rather than on examination. We screen for these before treating, and where one applies we refer you on with a letter of findings rather than book you in.

See what questions people are searching for

Chiropractic at Brunswick Health — what treatment involves, who provides it and what it costs.

Related reading

All articles

Bookings

Get it looked at

Reading about it only goes so far. Book online, or call (03) 9380 8099 and we'll help you book the right service.

No payment needed to book · Confirmation by SMS · No referral needed